Recently in Google Category

Google: bête et méchant

user-pic
Vote 0 Votes

Have just got off the phone with Ohna and it seems that Google/Youtube's behaviour is even more absurd than I thought...

Ohna's film Son wasn't just posted by her production company. Oh no:

  • YouTube vetted a large number of independent film-makers for their "screening room" project and approached Ohna to ask her to participate.
  • Not only was Son hand-picked by Google, it was reviewed by an approval board and checked for copyright.
  • In an effort to promote the filmmakers, YouTube proposed that each film have a "buy now" button.

So let me get this straight. You go out and find the best films. You have lengthy conversations with the producers of each. You check each for quality and appropriateness of content and verify that each producer owns the right to broadcast the work.

Then, you nail them with a copyright-theft cease-and-desist and take down the film you've just spent months organising the screening of.

Never mind that this is just the worst possible PR job in the world. Isn't this frankly just downright stupid?

Well it used to be Big Oil or Big Business but we really are seeing the emergence of Big Copyright

Ohna's award-winning short film has been pulled by Google because of an automated copyright alert. This smells exactly the same as Google's ongoing mistreatment of the little guy. The same rules apply: justice cannot be applied by formula or filter. Unless each case is handled (note 'hand' as in 'human') individually by a trained adjudicator a never ending stream of injustice ensues.

I suggest Google work out how to pay for this adjudication service soon as sooner or later they're going to need a new business model...

Ohna reports:

Yesterday our short film SON was taken off YouTube's screening room because someone at Paramount Pictures copyright police company decided that maybe we had used some footage from Son Of Rambow. Whoever made this decision had obviously not watched the film as SON is obviously all original footage and in fact the only ressemblance to Paramount's film is the word SON in the title and the fact that there is a young boy in the cast. Despite the obvious blunder Paramount are making no effort to remedy the situation by removing their notice from YouTube and by doing so are damaging our reputation and possibly causing us loss of income.

The woman could use some words of support. Go comment on her post

And if you are aware of similar events, make you register each and every case with the EFF's chilling effects website.

Subject: Google Agency Party - Your Invitation

Dear [Fname]

We would love you to join us for a Party on the night of Thursday September 28th. We sent you an invitation this afternoon, but due to some technical difficulties on our side, the invitations were not sent in the correct format.

We will be resending your invitation shortly. Please look out for it and we do hope you will be able to join us.

All the best,
Valentina

Of course it being an advertising thing I'm sure most recipients replied as "fname".

Radiodonkey

OpenID accepted here Learn more about OpenID

VFTO

About this Archive

This page is an archive of recent entries in the Google category.

Find recent content on the main index or look in the archives to find all content.